[He resisted the urge to reach through the screen and strangle her. Okay, no, but really--]

Allison, god. You guys are still friends. How is showing that you care about a friend 'weird'? So you broke up. It happens. You both still obviously care about each other, otherwise you wouldn't have even bothered to answer, so just... care. Show him. The world won't end if you guys are in the same room together.