[Okay, so maybe he doesn't know so much about what witches can and can't do other than in stories. They're all fairly powerful there, so it had made some sort of sense in his head at the time. And his mouth does, of course, tug off to the side when she starts giggling - although, admittedly, she's pretty cute when she does that, and the expression doesn't last long.]

Oh, aye, I see. But ye know what one is, I'm guessing. Well enough so ye can tell the difference if I played these for ye now, right?